There’s only one way to pitch this week’s fash-off: let the battle of the ladies in red commence!

At style loggerheads this week is Vogue cover girl, Kate Upton and Hollywood darling Jennifer Love Hewitt, as both ladies sported the same Alexander McQueen cowl neck silk crepe dress, albeit to two very different events.

First up, Jennifer Love Hewitt painted the red carpet, well, red last May, at the A&E Network event in New York. Going sans accessories, Jennifer teamed the McQueen number with tan platform pumps and strong eyes, leaving her softly tousled hair down.

Fast forward to February 2013 and Kate Upton was spotted slipping into the same dress for an appearance on Late Night With Jimmy Fallon, in New York. Radiant and gorgeous as ever, Kate teamed the McQueen dress with black Louboutin pumps and a beaming smile.

Although both Jennifer and Kate opted for a similarly simple look, who’s style is worthy of the fash-off accolade? Sorry Jen, but we’re digging Kate on this one – the tan pumps don’t really do much for the dress. Other than heels, a McQueen dress doesn’t really need much else to have us gushing in awe, so have to be a good choice!

Whose style wins for you? Do you agree with our fash-off verdict?